Vin Diesel on D&D and Riddick

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Tuesday, 19 February 2013

Review: White Plume Mountain

Posted on 19:25 by rajrani
Caution: Spoilers (both of the novel and the modules it's based on).

Today I'm going to take you through another piece of Greyhawkiana that not everyone is familiar with; the novel White Plume Mountain by Paul Kidd. Published in 1999 to coincide with the release of the adventure module Return to White Plume Mountain, this is the second in the series of "Greyhawk Classics" novels and is better by far than its predecessor Against the Giants.

Although this novel is based on the original module of the same name, it doesn't make the mistake of simply being a recounting of the plot thereof. Indeed, it even references the events of the module as having taken place in past history (this novel takes place in CY 588) and shifts the action to the County of Urnst, which is teeming with Tenha refugees after Iuz destroyed the Duchy in the recent wars. We see the enchanted weapons Wave, Whelm, and Blackrazor, but they are now found in Trigol, and two of them are given some more interesting backstories than merely "powerful magic weapons in someone's collection." Wave, we find out, is sacred to Geshtai, goddess of rivers, and Whelm is sacred to Bleredd, god of metal, mining, and smiths.

Although the plot of the novel eventually takes the characters to the famed mountain, what I like about it is that they spend as much time along the borders of Urnst, or in the city of Trigol, as they do inside the mountain itself. That gives a lot of opportunity not only to explore the characters and build up their relationships, but also to define some of the setting itself, especially in places that haven't gotten a lot of attention, such as Trigol. There's also some interesting background on the political situation with the refugees in Urnst and the temple rivalries they've brought with them.

Even once we do get into the mountain itself, it's not a straight retread of either White Plume Mountain or Return to White Plume Mountain. There are certainly similarities, but things are subtly different to account for the intervening years, and the real villain's plot is subtly different from those in the adventure modules. I liked that; if one was using this as source material, there are some neat ideas and alternatives to be had.

What I really like about this book, though, are the characters. The novel's main character, a ranger called The Justicar, is certainly memorable, and would make a great NPC for a game. The same goes for his companions Cinder (a sentient hell hound pelt), Escalla (a perky and quirky faerie/pixie sorceress), and Polk, a kindly but annoying old wagon drover who is bound and determined to teach The Justicar what "real" adventurers are like.

There's no small amount of humor to be found, but the novel as a whole is serious. With some very memorable characters and nice background that fleshes out aspects of the Flanaess that we've never seen before, I am very pleased indeed with this entry into the Greyhawk novel arena.

I give it four wizards out of five.




Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in Books, Greyhawk Novels, RPG, World of Greyhawk | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Bestiary Cover
    Christian N. St. Pierre , the artist who did the covers for the Adventures Dark and Deep™ Players Manual and Game Masters Toolkit , has com...
  • More Greyhawk Heraldry
    I thought I'd knock out some of the easier ones this time. As before , these were done using the wonderful Coat of Arms Visual Designer ...
  • Google+ OSR Community
    For those who don't know, on Thursday Google+ unveiled a new feature; Communities. Basically, a G+ Community is a place where folks can ...
  • Yet More Greyhawk Heraldry
    I needed to take a writing break, so in my idle moments I put together some more heraldic devices from the World of Greyhawk. As before, the...
  • Happy First Contact Day!
    Star Trek lore tells us that on this date in the year 2063, space pioneer Zephram Cochrane, inventor of warp drive, will make first contact ...
  • Review: White Plume Mountain
    Caution: Spoilers (both of the novel and the modules it's based on). Today I'm going to take you through another piece of Greyhawkia...
  • The Beanstalk: An Alternate Setting for Metamorphosis Alpha/Gamma World
    Much as I love the venerable Metamorphosis Alpha, I was never too taken by the setting of the Starship Warden. The design of the ship (essen...
  • Review: Queen of the Demonweb Pits
    Caution: Spoilers (both of the novel and the module it's based on) We come now to the final volume of Paul Kidd's Greyhawk trilogy, ...
  • A Truly Awesome Greyhawk Calendar
    Done by Russell Akred, posted over at the Flanaess Geographical Society on Facebook . I only wish there was a larger version out there (clic...
  • Can Fandom Change Society?
    I came across this interesting video today from PBS: On the whole, I found the concept to be pretty good, but their choices of fandoms to fo...

Categories

  • 0E (3)
  • 13 Days of Halloween (11)
  • 1E (18)
  • 2E (7)
  • 3E (3)
  • 4E (4)
  • 5E (28)
  • ADD (76)
  • Admin (5)
  • AGG (3)
  • animation (3)
  • Apes (1)
  • appearances (5)
  • Aquaria (1)
  • arrows of indra (1)
  • art (4)
  • Batman (5)
  • Black Blade (1)
  • Blogosphere douchebaggery (1)
  • Board Games (25)
  • Books (13)
  • BRW Games (22)
  • Campaign Design (8)
  • Campaign Journal (4)
  • card games (2)
  • Cartography (21)
  • Castle Greyhawk (1)
  • Castle of the Mad Archmage (11)
  • Character Classes (2)
  • Chroniques de la Lune Noire (6)
  • City of Greyhawk (3)
  • Combat (3)
  • Computer Games (2)
  • Conventions (25)
  • DCC (5)
  • Derp (2)
  • Design Theory (1)
  • DMing tricks (10)
  • Doctor Who (1)
  • Erseta (20)
  • fandom (4)
  • Fantasy Flight Games (3)
  • Field of Glory (12)
  • Film Reviews (9)
  • films (34)
  • forgotten realms (2)
  • Game Design (23)
  • Game of Thrones (1)
  • Game Reviews (5)
  • Games I Love (1)
  • games workshop (3)
  • Gaming Industry (23)
  • Gamma World (1)
  • Glitterdark (4)
  • Greyhawk Comics (2)
  • Greyhawk Novels (8)
  • Grognardish Grumpiness (1)
  • Gygax (4)
  • Gygax Magazine (4)
  • Heraldry (4)
  • history (20)
  • horror (2)
  • Iron League Campaign (2)
  • John Carter film (2)
  • Kenzer (1)
  • Kickstarter (17)
  • LARP (2)
  • LotFP (2)
  • Magic (4)
  • Mass Battle (1)
  • megadungeons (4)
  • Mentzer (1)
  • Metamorphosis Alpha (1)
  • Miniatures (59)
  • monsters (10)
  • Music (2)
  • My Campaign (18)
  • NaGaDeMon (2)
  • News (20)
  • Ogre-GEV (20)
  • Old School (9)
  • Pathfinder (4)
  • PBM games (1)
  • Play Theory (2)
  • Religion (1)
  • Retro Clones (3)
  • RPG (349)
  • RPG Blog Carnival (1)
  • RuneQuest (1)
  • Satanic panic (1)
  • Savage Worlds (1)
  • Setting Design (2)
  • Skills (1)
  • Space (5)
  • Star Trek (11)
  • Star Wars (7)
  • Stronghold Games (2)
  • Sundered Empire (4)
  • superheroes (1)
  • T1-4 (1)
  • Television (13)
  • The RPG Industry (17)
  • Tolkien (7)
  • Traveller (1)
  • TSR (2)
  • UE (1)
  • Video Games (1)
  • Wargames (60)
  • Whimsy (40)
  • World of Greyhawk (54)
  • Worthy Causes (6)
  • WotC (30)

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (124)
    • ►  June (14)
    • ►  May (29)
    • ►  April (15)
    • ►  March (21)
    • ▼  February (27)
      • Adventures Dark and Deep G+ Community Now Open
      • Review: Tempest's Gate
      • Don't Call Them Clones
      • Review: Descent into the Depths of the Earth
      • Ogre Miniatures at Dreamation 2013
      • Review: Curse of the Weaver Queen
      • Thieves' Tools
      • Legendary Realms Terrain Kickstarter
      • Dreamation 2013 After-Action Report
      • Well *that* sucks...
      • Review: White Plume Mountain
      • A Definition of "Old School"
      • ADD Game Masters Toolkit - No Kickstarter
      • Kickstarter Thoughts
      • Dreamation Convention Schedule Now Up
      • Help Out Ernie Gygax
      • Review: Against the Giants
      • "The Treasure of Welthorp" Now Available
      • New York Toy Fair 2013
      • WotC Reprints and the OSR
      • Space Marine Victory!
      • More Games Workshop Legal Shenanigans
      • God Made a Gamer
      • Great Interview with Frank Mentzer
      • James Raggi vs. Kickstarter, Part Deux
      • Hasbro Announces 10% Workforce Cut
      • Space Shuttle Columbia
    • ►  January (18)
  • ►  2012 (335)
    • ►  December (29)
    • ►  November (16)
    • ►  October (30)
    • ►  September (16)
    • ►  August (23)
    • ►  July (30)
    • ►  June (29)
    • ►  May (32)
    • ►  April (45)
    • ►  March (26)
    • ►  February (24)
    • ►  January (35)
  • ►  2011 (41)
    • ►  December (37)
    • ►  November (4)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

rajrani
View my complete profile